IN THE GRAND COURT OF THE CAYMAN ISLANDS
CIVIL DIVISION
Cause No: G 442/2011
**BETWEEN:**
**DONALD CHARLES MINTO**
**PLAINTIFF**
**AND:**
**UNIT CONSTRUCTION LIMITED**
**DEFENDANT**
**Appearances:**
Mrs. Terry Caudeiron of TMC Chambers for the Plaintiff
Mr. Orren Merren of Orren Merren & Company for the Defendant
**Before:**
Mr. Justice Malcolm Swift Q.C. (Actg.)
**Heard:**
27 th April 2017
HEADNOTE
Civil Division – Personal Injury – Special and General Damages – Test to be applied on application to vary default Judgment to allege contributory negligence and to deploy evidence of contributory negligence at the hearing listed for the assessment of damages - Real prospect of success - Extent to which Defendant’s behaviour to be taken into account – s.64 of the Labour Law (2011) – GCR O.13 r.9 and O.25 r.4 - Overriding objective of the GCR.
Judgment. Cause No. G 442/2011. Donald Charles Minto v Unit Construction Limited. Coram Swift J. Actg. Date: 1.05.2017
JUDGMENT
1
2
3
4
On the 27th April 2017， at the conclusion of the hearing， in chambers， of this
5
interlocutory Summons issued on behalf of the Defendant on the 22nd February 2017， I
6
gave my decision but indicated (in the light of Mr Merren's expressed dissatisfaction
7
with the outcome) that I would provide brief reasons in writing for my decision.
8
2.
The application made by the Defendant was for supplementary directions (additional to
9
the directions contained in the Order for Directions made on the 7th October 2016)
10
namely：
11
a. That the Plaintiff's refusal and/or neglect to admit the facts requested by the
12
Defendant's Notice to Admit dated 3rd February 2017 be taken into account for the
13
purposes of the Preamble to the GCR and of GCR O.25， r4；
14
b. That in properly assessing the special and general damages awarded to the Plaintiff
15
by way of an interlocutory default judgment dated 14th December 2011， the
16
Defendant be allowed to present evidence of the Plaintiff's contributory negligence
17
in causing the injuries he suffered on or about 11th November 2011； and
18
c. That such evidence of the Plaintiff's contributory negligence be considered when
19
properly assessing such special and general damages and (as relevant) to reduce
20
the net quantum thereof accordingly.
21
The arther requ
3pplication futed variat
23
the content of b) and c) above)， with liberty to apply， further or other relief and an
24
order for costs to be provided for.
Judgment. Cause No. G 442/2011. Donald Charles Minto v Unit Construction Limited. Coram Swift J. Actg. Date：1.05.2017
1
4.
After consideration of all the documentation submitted in the case including the skeleton arguments supplemented by oral submissions from Mr Merren, I did not feel it necessary to call upon the Plaintiff to respond as, in my view, the application was ill-founded. Therefore, the summons was dismissed.
5
5.
The Plaintiffs cross-summons for directions was granted (it is not necessary here to set out the particular directions made as they followed the content of the summons) but with one variation namely:
8
a.
That the Defendant was allowed 28 days from the 27th April 2017 to arrange for the Plaintiff to be examined by a defence medical expert;
10
b.
That the Defendant was allowed until the 16th June 2017 for the service on the Plaintiff of any expert medical report to be relied upon;
12
c.
That the Defendant to be debarred from calling expert medical evidence absent compliance with that timetable;
14
d.
That the Plaintiff to be at liberty to respond with supplemental medical expert evidence if so advised.
16
6.
I ordered that the Plaintiffs costs of the hearing be assessed by the legal aid authorities and paid by the Defendant within 14 days of notification of the assessment.
18
7.
I rely, in the usual way, upon the parties to draw up the above order.
\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath}
\usepackage{geometry}
\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage{hyperref}
\usepackage{titlesec}
\usepackage{fancyhdr}
\usepackage{lastpage}
\usepackage{datetime}
\usepackage{datetime2}
\usepackage{datetime3}
\usepackage{datetime4}
\usepackage{datetime5}
\usepackage{datetime6}
\usepackage{datetime7}
\usepackage{datetime8}
\usepackage{datetime9}
\usepackage{datetime10}
\usepackage{datetime11}
\usepackage{datetime12}
\usepackage{datetime13}
\usepackage{datetime14}
\usepackage{datetime15}
\usepackage{datetime16}
\usepackage{datetime17}
\usepackage{datetime18}
\usepackage{datetime19}
\usepackage{datetime20}
\usepackage{datetime21}
\usepackage{datetime22}
\usepackage{datetime23}
\usepackage{datetime24}
\usepackage{datetime25}
\usepackage{datetime26}
\usepackage{datetime27}
\usepackage{datetime28}
\usepackage{datetime29}
\usepackage{datetime30}
\usepackage{datetime31}
\usepackage{datetime32}
\usepackage{datetime33}
\usepackage{datetime34}
\usepackage{datetime35}
\usepackage{datetime36}
\usepackage{datetime37}
\usepackage{datetime38}
\usepackage{datetime39}
\usepackage{datetime40}
\usepackage{datetime41}
\usepackage{datetime42}
\usepackage{datetime43}
\usepackage{datetime44}
\usepackage{datetime45}
\usepackage{datetime46}
\usepackage{datetime47}
\usepackage{datetime48}
\usepackage{datetime49}
\usepackage{datetime50}
\usepackage{datetime51}
\usepackage{datetime52}
\usepackage{datetime53}
\usepackage{datetime54}
\usepackage{datetime55}
\usepackage{datetime56}
\usepackage{datetime57}
\usepackage{datetime58}
\usepackage{datetime59}
\usepackage{datetime60}
\usepackage{datetime61}
\usepackage{datetime62}
\usepackage{datetime63}
\usepackage{datetime64}
\usepackage{datetime65}
\usepackage{datetime66}
\usepackage{datetime67}
\usepackage{datetime68}
\usepackage{datetime69}
\usepackage{datetime70}
\usepackage{datetime71}
\usepackage{datetime72}
\usepackage{datetime73}
\usepackage{datetime74}
\usepackage{datetime75}
\usepackage{datetime76}
\usepackage{datetime77}
\usepackage{datetime78}
\usepackage{datetime79}
\usepackage{datetime80}
\usepackage{datetime81}
\usepackage{datetime82}
\usepackage{datetime83}
\usepackage{datetime84}
\usepackage{datetime85}
\usepackage{datetime86}
\usepackage{datetime87}
\usepackage{datetime88}
\usepackage{datetime89}
\usepackage{datetime90}
\usepackage{datetime91}
\usepackage{datetime92}
\usepackage{datetime93}
\usepackage{datetime94}
\usepackage{datetime95}
\usepackage{datetime96}
\usepackage{datetime97}
\usepackage{datetime98}
\usepackage{datetime99}
\usepackage{datetime100}
\usepackage{datetime101}
\usepackage{datetime102}
\usepackage{datetime103}
\usepackage{datetime104}
\usepackage{datetime105}
\usepackage{datetime106}
\usepackage{datetime107}
\usepackage{datetime108}
\usepackage{datetime109}
\usepackage{datetime110}
\usepackage{datetime111}
\usepackage{datetime112}
\usepackage{datetime113}
\usepackage{datetime114}
\usepackage{datetime115}
\usepackage{datetime116}
\usepackage{datetime117}
\usepackage{datetime118}
\usepackage{datetime119}
\usepackage{datetime120}
\usepackage{datetime121}
\usepackage{datetime122}
\usepackage{datetime123}
\usepackage{datetime124}
\usepackage{datetime125}
\usepackage{datetime126}
\usepackage{datetime127}
\usepackage{datetime128}
\usepackage{datetime129}
\usepackage{datetime130}
\usepackage{datetime131}
\usepackage{datetime132}
\usepackage{datetime133}
\usepackage{datetime134}
\usepackage{datetime135}
\usepackage{datetime136}
\usepackage{datetime137}
\usepackage{datetime138}
\usepackage{datetime139}
\usepackage{datetime140}
\usepackage{datetime141}
\usepackage{datetime142}
\usepackage{datetime143}
\usepackage{datetime144}
\usepackage{datetime145}
\usepackage{datetime146}
\usepackage{datetime147}
\usepackage{datetime148}
\usepackage{datetime149}
\usepackage{datetime150}
\usepackage{datetime151}
\usepackage{datetime152}
\usepackage{datetime153}
\usepackage{datetime154}
\usepackage{datetime155}
\usepackage{datetime156}
\usepackage{datetime157}
\usepackage{datetime158}
\usepackage{datetime159}
\usepackage{datetime160}
\usepackage{datetime161}
\usepackage{datetime162}
\usepackage{datetime163}
\usepackage{datetime164}
\usepackage{datetime165}
\usepackage{datetime166}
\usepackage{datetime167}
\usepackage{datetime168}
\usepackage{datetime169}
\usepackage{datetime170}
\usepackage{datetime171}
\usepackage{datetime172}
\usepackage{datetime173}
\usepackage{datetime174}
\usepackage{datetime175}
\usepackage{datetime176}
\usepackage{datetime177}
\usepackage{datetime178}
\usepackage{datetime179}
\usepackage{datetime180}
\usepackage{datetime181}
\usepackage{datetime182}
\usepackage{datetime183}
\usepackage{datetime184}
\usepackage{datetime185}
\usepackage{datetime186}
\usepackage{datetime187}
\usepackage{datetime188}
\usepackage{datetime189}
\usepackage{datetime190}
\usepackage{datetime191}
\usepackage{datetime192}
\usepackage{datetime193}
\usepackage{datetime194}
\usepackage{datetime195}
\usepackage{datetime196}
\usepackage{datetime197}
\usepackage{datetime198}
\usepackage{datetime199}
\usepackage{datetime200}
\usepackage{datetime201}
\usepackage{datetime202}
\usepackage{datetime203}
\usepackage{datetime204}
\usepackage{datetime205}
\usepackage{datetime206}
\usepackage{datetime207}
\usepackage{datetime208}
\usepackage{datetime209}
\usepackage{datetime210}
\usepackage{datetime211}
\usepackage{datetime212}
\usepackage{datetime213}
\usepackage{datetime214}
\usepackage{datetime215}
\usepackage{datetime216}
\usepackage{datetime217}
\usepackage{datetime218}
\usepackage{datetime219}
\usepackage{datetime220}
\usepackage{datetime221}
\usepackage{datetime222}
\usepackage{datetime223}
\usepackage{datetime224}
\usepackage{datetime225}
\usepackage{datetime226}
\usepackage{datetime227}
\usepackage{datetime228}
\usepackage{datetime229}
\usepackage{datetime230}
\usepackage{datetime231}
\usepackage{datetime232}
\usepackage{datetime233}
\usepackage{datetime234}
\usepackage{datetime235}
\usepackage{datetime236}
\usepackage{datetime237}
\usepackage{datetime238}
\usepackage{datetime239}
\usepackage{datetime240}
\usepackage{datetime241}
\usepackage{datetime242}
\usepackage{datetime243}
\usepackage{datetime244}
\usepackage{datetime245}
\usepackage{datetime246}
\usepackage{datetime247}
\usepackage{datetime248}
\usepackage{datetime249}
\usepackage{datetime250}
\usepackage{datetime251}
\usepackage{datetime252}
\usepackage{datetime253}
\usepackage{datetime254}
\usepackage{datetime255}
\usepackage{datetime256}
\usepackage{datetime257}
\usepackage{datetime258}
\usepackage{datetime259}
\usepackage{datetime260}
\usepackage{datetime261}
\usepackage{datetime262}
\usepackage{datetime263}
\usepackage{datetime264}
\usepackage{datetime265}
\usepackage{datetime266}
\usepackage{datetime267}
\usepackage{datetime268}
\usepackage{datetime269}
\usepackage{datetime270}
\usepackage{datetime271}
\usepackage{datetime272}
\usepackage{datetime273}
\usepackage{datetime274}
\usepackage{datetime275}
\usepackage{datetime276}
\usepackage{datetime277}
\usepackage{datetime278}
\usepackage{datetime279}
\usepackage{datetime280}
\usepackage{datetime281}
\usepackage{datetime282}
\usepackage{datetime283}
\usepackage{datetime284}
\usepackage{datetime285}
\usepackage{datetime286}
\usepackage{datetime287}
\usepackage{datetime288}
\usepackage{datetime289}
\usepackage{datetime290}
\usepackage{datetime291}
\usepackage{datetime292}
\usepackage{datetime293}
\usepackage{datetime294}
\usepackage{datetime295}
\usepackage{datetime296}
\usepackage{datetime297}
\usepackage{datetime298}
\usepackage{datetime299}
\usepackage{datetime300}
\usepackage{datetime301}
\usepackage{datetime302}
\usepackage{datetime303}
\usepackage{datetime304}
\usepackage{datetime305}
\usepackage{datetime306}
\usepackage{datetime307}
\usepackage{datetime308}
\usepackage{datetime309}
\usepackage{datetime310}
\usepackage{datetime311}
\usepackage{datetime312}
\usepackage{datetime313}
\usepackage{datetime314}
\usepackage{datetime315}
\usepackage{datetime316}
\usepackage{datetime317}
\usepackage{datetime318}
\usepackage{datetime319}
\usepackage{datetime320}
\usepackage{datetime321}
\usepackage{datetime322}
\usepackage{datetime323}
\usepackage{datetime324}
\usepackage{datetime325}
\usepackage{datetime326}
\usepackage{datetime327}
\usepackage{datetime328}
\usepackage{datetime329}
\usepackage{datetime330}
\usepackage{datetime331}
\usepackage{datetime332}
\usepackage{datetime333}
\usepackage{datetime334}
\usepackage{datetime335}
\usepackage{datetime336}
\usepackage{datetime337}
\usepackage{datetime338}
\usepackage{datetime339}
\usepackage{datetime340}
\usepackage{datetime341}
\usepackage{datetime342}
\usepackage{datetime343}
\usepackage{datetime344}
\usepackage{datetime345}
\usepackage{datetime346}
\usepackage{datetime347}
\usepackage{datetime348}
\usepackage{datetime349}
\usepackage{datetime350}
\usepackage{datetime351}
\usepackage{datetime352}
\usepackage{datetime353}
\usepackage{datetime354}
\usepackage{datetime355}
\usepackage{datetime356}
\usepackage{datetime357}
\usepackage{datetime358}
\usepackage{datetime359}
\usepackage{datetime360}
\usepackage{datetime361}
\usepackage{datetime362}
\usepackage{datetime363}
\usepackage{datetime364}
\usepackage{datetime365}
\usepackage{datetime366}
\usepackage{datetime367}
\usepackage{datetime368}
\usepackage{datetime369}
\usepackage{datetime370}
\usepackage{datetime371}
\usepackage{datetime372}
\usepackage{datetime373}
\usepackage{datetime374}
\usepackage{datetime375}
\usepackage{datetime376}
\usepackage{datetime377}
\usepackage{datetime378}
\usepackage{datetime379}
\usepackage{datetime380}
\usepackage{datetime381}
\usepackage{datetime382}
\usepackage{datetime383}
\usepackage{datetime384}
\usepackage{datetime385}
\usepackage{datetime386}
\usepackage{datetime387}
\usepackage{datetime388}
\usepackage{datetime389}
\usepackage{datetime390}
\usepackage{datetime391}
\usepackage{datetime392}
\usepackage{datetime393}
\usepackage{datetime394}
\usepackage{datetime395}
\usepackage{datetime396}
\usepackage{datetime397}
\usepackage{datetime398}
\usepackage{datetime399}
\usepackage{datetime400}
\usepackage{datetime401}
\usepackage{datetime402}
\usepackage{datetime403}
\usepackage{datetime404}
\usepackage{datetime405}
\usepackage{datetime406}
\usepackage{datetime407}
\usepackage{datetime408}
\usepackage{datetime409}
\usepackage{datetime410}
\usepackage{datetime411}
\usepackage{datetime412}
\usepackage{datetime413}
\usepackage{datetime414}
\usepackage{datetime415}
\usepackage{datetime416}
\usepackage{datetime417}
\usepackage{datetime418}
\usepackage{datetime419}
\usepackage{datetime420}
\usepackage{datetime421}
\usepackage{datetime422}
\usepackage{datetime423}
\usepackage{datetime424}
\usepackage{datetime425}
\usepackage{datetime426}
\usepackage{datetime427}
\usepackage{datetime428}
\usepackage{datetime429}
\usepackage{datetime430}
\usepackage{datetime431}
\usepackage{datetime432}
\usepackage{datetime433}
\usepackage{datetime434}
\usepackage{datetime435}
\usepackage{datetime436}
\usepackage{datetime437}
\usepackage{datetime438}
\usepackage{datetime439}
\usepackage{datetime440}
\usepackage{datetime441}
\usepackage{datetime442}
\usepackage{datetime443}
\usepackage{datetime444}
\usepackage{datetime445}
\usepackage{datetime446}
\usepackage{datetime447}
\usepackage{datetime448}
\usepackage{datetime449}
\usepackage{datetime450}
\usepackage{datetime451}
\usepackage{datetime452}
\usepackage{datetime453}
\usepackage{datetime454}
\usepackage{datetime455}
\usepackage{datetime456}
\usepackage{datetime457}
\usepackage{datetime458}
\usepackage{datetime459}
\usepackage{datetime460}
\usepackage{datetime461}
\usepackage{datetime462}
\usepackage{datetime463}
\usepackage{datetime464}
\usepackage{datetime465}
\usepackage{datetime466}
\usepackage{datetime467}
\usepackage{datetime468}
\usepackage{datetime469}
\usepackage{datetime470}
\usepackage{datetime471}
\usepackage{datetime472}
\usepackage{datetime473}
\usepackage{datetime474}
\usepackage{datetime475}
\usepackage{datetime476}
\usepackage{datetime477}
\usepackage{datetime478}
\usepackage{datetime479}
\usepackage{datetime480}
\usepackage{datetime481}
\usepackage{datetime482}
\usepackage{datetime483}
\usepackage{datetime484}
\usepackage{datetime485}
\usepackage{datetime486}
\usepackage{datetime487}
\usepackage{datetime488}
\usepackage{datetime489}
\usepackage{datetime490}
\usepackage{datetime491}
\usepackage{datetime492}
\usepackage{datetime493}
\usepackage{datetime494}
\usepackage{datetime495}
\usepackage{datetime496}
\usepackage{datetime497}
\usepackage{datetime498}
\usepackage{datetime499}
\usepackage{datetime500}
\usepackage{datetime501}
\usepackage{datetime502}
\usepackage{datetime503}
\usepackage{datetime504}
\usepackage{datetime505}
\usepackage{datetime506}
\usepackage{datetime507}
\usepackage{datetime508}
\usepackage{datetime509}
\usepackage{datetime510}
\usepackage{datetime511}
\usepackage{datetime512}
\usepackage{datetime513}
\usepackage{datetime514}
\usepackage{datetime515}
\usepackage{datetime516}
\usepackage{datetime517}
\usepackage{datetime518}
\usepackage{datetime519}
\usepackage{datetime520}
\usepackage{datetime521}
\usepackage{datetime522}
\usepackage{datetime523}
\usepackage{datetime524}
\usepackage{datetime525}
\usepackage{datetime526}
\usepackage{datetime527}
\usepackage{datetime528}
\usepackage{datetime529}
\usepackage{datetime530}
\usepackage{datetime531}
\usepackage{datetime532}
\usepackage{datetime533}
\usepackage{datetime534}
\usepackage{datetime535}
\usepackage{datetime536}
\usepackage{datetime537}
\usepackage{datetime538}
\usepackage{datetime539}
\usepackage{datetime540}
\usepackage{datetime541}
\usepackage{datetime542}
\usepackage{datetime543}
\usepackage{datetime544}
\usepackage{datetime545}
\usepackage{datetime546}
\usepackage{datetime547}
\usepackage{datetime548}
\usepackage{datetime549}
\usepackage{datetime550}
\usepackage{datetime551}
\usepackage{datetime552}
\usepackage{datetime553}
\usepackage{datetime554}
\usepackage{datetime555}
\usepackage{datetime556}
\usepackage{datetime557}
\usepackage{datetime558}
\usepackage{datetime559}
\usepackage{datetime560}
\usepackage{datetime561}
\usepackage{datetime562}
\usepackage{datetime563}
\usepackage{datetime564}
\usepackage{datetime565}
\usepackage{datetime566}
\usepackage{datetime567}
\usepackage{datetime568}
\usepackage{datetime569}
\usepackage{datetime570}
\usepackage{datetime571}
\usepackage{datetime572}
\usepackage{datetime573}
\usepackage{datetime574}
\usepackage{datetime575}
\usepackage{datetime576}
\usepackage{datetime577}
\usepackage{datetime578}
\usepackage{datetime579}
\usepackage{datetime580}
\usepackage{datetime581}
\usepackage{datetime582}
\usepackage{datetime583}
\usepackage{datetime584}
\usepackage{datetime585}
\usepackage{datetime586}
\usepackage{datetime587}
\usepackage{datetime588}
\usepackage{datetime589}
\usepackage{datetime590}
\usepackage{datetime591}
\usepackage{datetime592}
\usepackage{datetime593}
\usepackage{datetime594}
\usepackage{datetime595}
\usepackage{datetime596}
\usepackage{datetime597}
\usepackage{datetime598}
\usepackage{datetime599}
\usepackage{datetime600}
\usepackage{datetime601}
\usepackage{datetime602}
\usepackage{datetime603}
\usepackage{datetime604}
\usepackage{datetime605}
\usepackage{datetime606}
\usepackage{datetime607}
\usepackage{datetime608}
\usepackage{datetime609}
\usepackage{datetime610}
\usepackage{datetime611}
\usepackage{datetime612}
\usepackage{datetime613}
\usepackage{datetime614}
\usepackage{datetime615}
\usepackage{datetime616}
\usepackage{datetime617}
\usepackage{datetime618}
\usepackage{datetime619}
\usepackage{datetime620}
\usepackage{datetime621}
\usepackage{datetime622}
\usepackage{datetime623}
\usepackage{datetime624}
\usepackage{datetime625}
\usepackage{datetime626}
\usepackage{datetime627}
\usepackage{datetime628}
\usepackage{datetime629}
\usepackage{datetime630}
\usepackage{datetime631}
\usepackage{datetime632}
\usepackage{datetime633}
\usepackage{datetime634}
\usepackage{datetime635}
\usepackage{datetime636}
\usepackage{datetime637}
\usepackage{datetime638}
\usepackage{datetime639}
\usepackage{datetime640}
\usepackage{datetime641}
\usepackage{datetime642}
\usepackage{datetime643}
\usepackage{datetime644}
\usepackage{datetime645}
\usepackage{datetime646}
\usepackage{datetime647}
\usepackage{datetime648}
\usepackage{datetime649}
\usepackage{datetime650}
\usepackage{datetime651}
\usepackage{datetime652}
\usepackage{datetime653}
\usepackage{datetime654}
\usepackage{datetime655}
\usepackage{datetime656}
\usepackage{datetime657}
\usepackage{datetime658}
\usepackage{datetime659}
\usepackage{datetime660}
\usepackage{datetime661}
\usepackage{datetime662}
\usepackage{datetime663}
\usepackage{datetime664}
\usepackage{datetime665}
\usepackage{datetime666}
\usepackage{datetime667}
\usepackage{datetime668}
\usepackage{datetime669}
\usepackage{datetime670}
\usepackage{datetime671}
\usepackage{datetime672}
\usepackage{datetime673}
\usepackage{datetime674}
\usepackage{datetime675}
\usepackage{datetime676}
\usepackage{datetime677}
\usepackage{datetime678}
\usepackage{datetime679}
\usepackage{datetime680}
\usepackage{datetime681}
\usepackage{datetime682}
\usepackage{datetime683}
\usepackage{datetime684}
\usepackage{datetime685}
\usepackage{datetime686}
\usepackage{datetime687}
\usepackage{datetime688}
\usepackage{datetime689}
\usepackage{datetime690}
\usepackage{datetime691}
\usepackage{datetime692}
\usepackage{datetime693}
\usepackage{datetime694}
\usepackage{datetime695}
\usepackage{datetime696}
\usepackage{datetime697}
\usepackage{datetime698}
\usepackage{datetime699}
\usepackage{datetime700}
\usepackage{datetime701}
\usepackage{datetime702}
\usepackage{datetime703}
\usepackage{datetime704}
\usepackage{datetime705}
\usepackage{datetime706}
\usepackage{datetime707}
\usepackage{datetime708}
\usepackage{datetime709}
\usepackage{datetime710}
\usepackage{datetime711}
\usepackage{datetime712}
\usepackage{datetime713}
\usepackage{datetime714}
\usepackage{datetime715}
\usepackage{datetime716}
\usepackage{datetime717}
\usepackage{datetime718}
\usepackage{datetime719}
\usepackage{datetime720}
\usepackage{datetime721}
\usepackage{datetime722}
\usepackage{datetime723}
\usepackage{datetime724}
\usepackage{datetime725}
\usepackage{datetime726}
\usepackage{datetime727}
\usepackage{datetime728}
\usepackage{datetime729}
\usepackage{datetime730}
\usepackage{datetime731}
\usepackage{datetime732}
\usepackage{datetime733}
\usepackage{datetime734}
\usepackage{datetime735}
\usepackage{datetime736}
\usepackage{datetime737}
\usepackage{datetime738}
\usepackage{datetime739}
\usepackage{datetime740}
\usepackage{datetime741}
\usepackage{datetime742}
\usepackage{datetime743}
\usepackage{datetime744}
\usepackage{datetime745}
\usepackage{datetime746}
\usepackage{datetime747}
\usepackage{datetime748}
\usepackage{datetime749}
\usepackage{datetime750}
\usepackage{datetime751}
\usepackage{datetime752}
\usepackage{datetime753}
\usepackage{datetime754}
\usepackage{datetime755}
\usepackage{datetime756}
\usepackage{datetime757}
\usepackage{datetime758}
\usepackage{datetime759}
\usepackage{datetime760}
\usepackage{datetime761}
\usepackage{datetime762}
\usepackage{datetime763}
\usepackage{datetime764}
\usepackage{datetime765}
\usepackage{datetime766}
\usepackage{datetime767}
\usepackage{datetime768}
\usepackage{datetime769}
\usepackage{datetime770}
\usepackage{datetime771}
\usepackage{datetime772}
\usepackage{datetime773}
\usepackage{datetime774}
\usepackage{datetime775}
\usepackage{datetime776}
\usepackage{datetime777}
\usepackage{datetime778}
\usepackage{datetime779}
\usepackage{datetime780}
\usepackage{datetime781}
\usepackage{datetime782}
\usepackage{datetime783}
\usepackage{datetime784}
\usepackage{datetime785}
\usepackage{datetime786}
\usepackage{datetime787}
\usepackage{datetime788}
\usepackage{datetime789}
\usepackage{datetime790}
\usepackage{datetime791}
\usepackage{datetime792}
\usepackage{datetime793}
\usepackage{datetime794}
\usepackage{datetime795}
\usepackage{datetime796}
\usepackage{datetime797}
\usepackage{datetime798}
\usepackage{datetime799}
\usepackage{datetime800}
\usepackage{datetime801}
\usepackage{datetime802}
\usepackage{datetime803}
\usepackage{datetime804}
\usepackage{datetime805}
\usepackage{datetime806}
\usepackage{datetime807}
\usepackage{datetime808}
\usepackage{datetime809}
\usepackage{datetime810}
\usepackage{datetime811}
\usepackage{datetime812}
\usepackage{datetime813}
\usepackage{datetime814}
\usepackage{datetime815}
\usepackage{datetime816}
\usepackage{datetime817}
\usepackage{datetime818}
\usepackage{datetime819}
\usepackage{datetime820}
\usepackage{datetime821}
\usepackage{datetime822}
\usepackage{datetime823}
\usepackage{datetime824}
\usepackage{datetime825}
\usepackage{datetime826}
\usepackage{datetime827}
\usepackage{datetime828}
\usepackage{datetime829}
\usepackage{datetime830}
\usepackage{datetime831}
\usepackage{datetime832}
\usepackage{datetime833}
\usepackage{datetime834}
\usepackage{datetime835}
\usepackage{datetime836}
\usepackage{datetime837}
\usepackage{datetime838}
\usepackage{datetime839}
\use
1
ANALYSIS
2
8.
The issue at the hearing on the 27th April 2017 was whether the Defendant should be
3
permitted to adduce evidence of contributory negligence at the hearing scheduled for
4
the assessment of damages in August 2017.
5
9.
The Plaintiff was seriously injured in an accident at work on the 11th November 2010.
6
The writ was issued on the 8th November 2011 with statement of claim attached. The
7
Defendant, having been served with proceedings, failed to serve a defence. On the 14th
8
December 2011, an interlocutory default judgment was entered ordering an interim
9
payment with damages to be assessed. A judgment debtor examination was due
10
to take place on the 6th June 2012 but the Defendant instructed an attorney to appear and
11
the examination was adjourned. The Defendant was clearly informed by the court of
12
the right to apply to set the default judgment aside and provision was made for such an
13
application by allowing adequate time at the next hearing. The affidavit of the
14
managing director of the Defendant sworn on the 26th June 2012 stated that such an
15
application was to be made. It is clear therefore that the Defendant and its attorneys
16
had this well in mind in mid-2012. No such application was ever made. The
17
Defendant continued to be legally represented until late September 2013. It is also
18
noteworthy that the Defendant, even now, is not applying to set aside the default
19
judgment but instead to amend its terms to allow evidence of contributory negligence
20
to be presented at the hearing at which quantum is to be assessed. This application
21
seeksghshod over ural requir
22
to ride rougnormal procting to do a
23
the need for a leading theatt
24
formal, procedural and evidential consequences of such an allegation being made.
Judgment. Cause No. G 442/2011. Donald Charles Minto v Unit Construction Limited. Coram Swift J. Actg. Date: 1.05.2017
10.
I do not propose to set out the appalling delays and obfuscation caused by the
Defendant (see in particular paragraphs 12 to 26 of the Plaintiffs main submissions). I
am left with the overriding impression that the Defendant's principal aim is to disrupt
and delay the proper resolution of the Plaintiffs claim.
11.
In order to avoid yet another adjournment, when it was pointed out to Mr Merren that
the Defendant's managing director's affidavit (sworn 20th April 2017) sought to exhibit
unsworn witness statements asserting circumstances alleged to amount to contributory
negligence, I agreed to treat those statements as if they were in affidavit form for the
purposes of this hearing. The statements were recently made in November and
December 2016 by two current employees of the Defendant who were also employed
by the Defendant at the time of the accident. No explanation was provided for the five-
year delay prior to the statements being made. Neither employee saw the accident
occur and they speculate about the circumstances of it.
12.
The test to be applied by me is whether the suggested defence of contributory
negligence has any real prospect of success (I adopt but find it unnecessary to repeat
here the Plaintiffs submissions set out at paragraphs 42 to 50). I also take into account
the Defendant's responsibility for the unconscionable delay which has occurred in this
case.
13.
I have considered carefully the rival contentions as to the law applicable to the
statutory and common law duties of employer and employee arising out of the
circumstances of this accident.
Judgment. Cause No. G 442/2011. Donald Charles Minto v Unit Construction Limited. Coram Swift J. Actg. Date: 1.05.2017
The Defendant relies on s.64 of the Labour Law (2011 Revision) set out at paragraph 15 of the defence supplemental outline submissions. I am left dissatisfied with the suggestion that the Plaintiff was provided by the Defendant with any “means, appliances, conveniences or other things” for his “health, safety or welfare” capable of having prevented the events leading to him sustaining injury. On the contrary, the Plaintiff was using a tool which was, on the evidence, provided by the Defendant (albeit seeking to delegate the choice of equipment to the Plaintiff) though the circumstances of its use were unsupervised. It is not enough to leave a workman to carry out his work in the hope that he will be able to do so using potentially viable safeguards which may or may not be appropriate to the task or which may be impractical to deploy. It is not for the workman to ask the employer to do his duty to work out the best and safest way to perform the task. Rather it is for the employer to supervise the task and ensure that any available method of safeguarding is appropriate to the task, can be used in a practical and safe manner and is in fact so used (particularly where a task is being done for the first time using new and untested equipment).
Having read the statements upon which the Defendant relies, I am not satisfied that a case of contributory negligence arises on the basis of the facts asserted and certainly not one with a real prospect of success.
Judgment. Cause No. G 442/2011. Donald Charles Minto v Unit Construction Limited. Coram Swift J. Actg. Date: 1.05.2017
1
16.
I must also take into account the delay and obfuscation caused by the Defendant and
2
the consequent effect on the Plaintiff, his health and his recoverable net damages, the
3
Defendant's awareness of the availability of an assertion of contributory negligence as
4
long ago as 2012 (if not earlier as I must assume that any competent employer would
5
have investigated the circumstances of the accident at the time), the failure to make the
6
allegation sooner, the fact that the failure to apply to set the default judgment aside was
7
at a time when the Defendant had legal representation, the age of the case, the
8
increasing costs burden to the Legal Aid Fund and to the Plaintiff, the Defendant's
9
non-compliance with court orders and, as I find, the Defendant's failure to engage in
10
any meaningful attempts to resolve the issues in the case.
11
17.
The notice to admit, served by the Defendant, does not require a response as it is otiose
12
being dependent on contributory negligence becoming an issue in the case.
13
18.
Although it is not strictly necessary to decide the following issue on this application, I
14
have also concluded that the Defendant's submissions that the default judgment should
15
be amended as suggested are misconceived. A default judgment for unliquidated
16
damages may be varied under GCR O.13 r.9 on such terms as the court deems just.
17
However, because the issue raised is a fundamental issue of liability, variation is
18
inappropriate, amendment under any slip rule does not arise and it would therefore be
19
necessary to apply to the court to set the judgment aside.
Judgment. Cause No. G 442/2011. Donald Charles Minto v Unit Construction Limited. Coram Swift J. Actg. Date: 1.05.2017
In the light of my findings, such an application would fail. In any event, it appears that
this issue was raised by the Defendant at the directions hearing on the 7th October 2016
and the court declined to entertain an application to set aside on the basis that no
material was then before the court providing any grounds for such an application. The
Defendant has chosen yet again not to pursue any application to set aside choosing
instead to try to amend the judgment.
19. Finally my decision in this case relied on observance of the overriding objective of the
GCR with the aim of securing the just, most expeditious and least expensive resolution
of the case. I have taken into account and applied Rule 4 dealing with the court's duty
to manage proceedings so as to further the overriding objective. There must be no
further obstacles placed in the way of the August hearing and final resolution of this
claim.
Dated this the 1st day of May 2017
Honourable Mr. Justice Malcolm Swift Q.C. (Actg.)
Acting Judge of the Grand Court