Judgment · jid 5453 · pdb #3422
Renova Resources Private Equity Ltd v Brian Patrick Gilbertson et al - Ruling (Strike‑Out; Summary Judgment; Derivative Action Counterclaim)
FSD 0061/2010 (AFJ) · 2010-05-05
GCR O.18 r.19 strike‑out principles; “Plain and obvious” threshold; Counterclaim alleging breach of Letter Agreement, inducing breach, lawful/unlawful means conspiracy, and director indemnity; Whether issues suitable for summary disposal; Overlap with main derivative action; Extensive factual disputes and complex legal questions unsuitable for summary judgment; Refusal to strike out
All PDF copies on file (1)
Every PDF we hold for this judgment is listed here, including legacy versions pulled from earlier upstream pipelines. Each carries a provenance note so the source of each copy is explicit.
PDB
20 May 2026
CURRENT
10-05-05-Renova-Resources-Private-Equity-Limited-v-Brian-Patrick-Gilbertson-et-al.pdf
8.22 MB · md5 553cee5321aea7a797a304f3248fb36e
Downloaded 2026-05-20 from the new judicial.ky Participants-Database release at https://judicial.ky/n0c-storage/judgments-repository2/10-05-05-Renova-Resources-Private-Equity-Limited-v-Brian-Patrick-Gilbertson-et-al.pdf.
Full metadata
| Cause Number | FSD 0061/2010 (AFJ) |
|---|---|
| Court | CIGC (FSD) |
| Judge | Foster J |
| Parties | Renova Resources Private Equity Ltd v Brian Patrick Gilbertson et al - Ruling (Strike‑Out; Summary Judgment; Derivative Action Counterclaim) |
| Judgment Date | 2010-05-05 |
| Subject | GCR O.18 r.19 strike‑out principles; “Plain and obvious” threshold; Counterclaim alleging breach of Letter Agreement, inducing breach, lawful/unlawful means conspiracy, and director indemnity; Whether issues suitable for summary disposal; Overlap with main derivative action; Extensive factual disputes and complex legal questions unsuitable for summary judgment; Refusal to strike out |
| Filename (current) | 10-05-05-Renova-Resources-Private-Equity-Limited-v-Brian-Patrick-Gilbertson-et-al.pdf |
| File MD5 | 553cee5321aea7a797a304f3248fb36e |
| Source pipeline | pdb |
| PDB record ID | 3422 |
| PDB URL | https://judicial.ky/n0c-storage/judgments-repository2/10-05-05-Renova-Resources-Private-Equity-Limited-v-Brian-Patrick-Gilbertson-et-al.pdf |