Judgment · jid 4810 · pdb #2255
Marlene Samuels and Christaline McLaughlin v Michael McLaughlin - Judgment
G 0391/2003 · 2014-12-23
Rival claims of siblings to beneficial interest in family home; whether claims in equity of one sufficient to override legal title of the other. Validity of Severance Notice and affidavit allegedly renouncing joint tenancy; Mental capacity of transferor; Proprietary estoppel claim based on alleged promise and detriment; Burden of proof for beneficial tenancy in common under Registered Land Law
All PDF copies on file (2)
Every PDF we hold for this judgment is listed here, including legacy versions pulled from earlier upstream pipelines. Each carries a provenance note so the source of each copy is explicit.
PDB
20 May 2026
CURRENT
14-12-23_marlene_samuels_and_christaline_mclaughlin_v_michael_mclaughlin_3.pdf
1.01 MB · md5 7d76f2b105761f64ba100a4c08e2eca0
Downloaded 2026-05-20 from the new judicial.ky Participants-Database release at https://judicial.ky/n0c-storage/judgments-repository/14-12-23_marlene_samuels_and_christaline_mclaughlin_v_michael_mclaughlin_3.pdf.
CSV
13 Apr 2025
CURRENT
5U361KBJTU7S1DE608A2F43696C96175068D0F62367786EDD59A.pdf
536.15 KB · md5 3d1c51cdd612139de149c844ecabf5c0
Legacy box_files copy — originally downloaded under jid=349 from the now-frozen judicial.ky CSV pipeline (Box.com signed-URL AJAX action=dl_bfile). Kept on disk for reference; the PDB release is the canonical current version. | re-homed from jid=4810 (identity-slide repair 2026-06-12)
Full metadata
| Cause Number | G 0391/2003 |
|---|---|
| Court | CIGC (Civ) |
| Judge | Smellie CJ |
| Parties | Marlene Samuels and Christaline McLaughlin v Michael McLaughlin - Judgment |
| Judgment Date | 2014-12-23 |
| Subject | Rival claims of siblings to beneficial interest in family home; whether claims in equity of one sufficient to override legal title of the other. Validity of Severance Notice and affidavit allegedly renouncing joint tenancy; Mental capacity of transferor; Proprietary estoppel claim based on alleged promise and detriment; Burden of proof for beneficial tenancy in common under Registered Land Law |
| Filename (current) | 14-12-23_marlene_samuels_and_christaline_mclaughlin_v_michael_mclaughlin_3.pdf |
| File MD5 | 7d76f2b105761f64ba100a4c08e2eca0 |
| Source pipeline | pdb |
| PDB record ID | 2255 |
| PDB URL | https://judicial.ky/n0c-storage/judgments-repository/14-12-23_marlene_samuels_and_christaline_mclaughlin_v_michael_mclaughlin_3.pdf |