Judgment · jid 4054 · pdb #3927
AA (Trustee) v BB (Attorney for Heirs) - Reasons for Decision
FSD 0137/2019 (ASCJ) · 2020-02-14
Trustee's proposal for realisation and distribution of trust assets and winding up of the Trust - whether Trustee may benefit only the heirs of the Settlor rather than the wider class of discretionary beneficiaries – seeming conflict between wishes of Settlor for Shari'a-compliant distributions and typical common law classification of discretionary trust beneficiaries - whether Court should nonetheless grant approval of Trustee's proposal if arrived at reasonably and after proper inquiries.
All PDF copies on file (2)
Every PDF we hold for this judgment is listed here, including legacy versions pulled from earlier upstream pipelines. Each carries a provenance note so the source of each copy is explicit.
PDB
20 May 2026
CURRENT
20-02-14-AA-v-BB.pdf
11.5 MB · md5 03ae5f57ab3934341cc2532ac06397c2
Downloaded 2026-05-20 from the new judicial.ky Participants-Database release at https://judicial.ky/n0c-storage/judgments-repository2/20-02-14-AA-v-BB.pdf.
CSV
13 Apr 2025
CURRENT
5U2TMXK859S81EC0C5D37996C0A36BB7B33DF1460C19BBFD1A27.pdf
11.5 MB · md5 5515a03f9c7202b52028cd468106a236
Legacy box_files copy — originally downloaded under jid=1261 from the now-frozen judicial.ky CSV pipeline (Box.com signed-URL AJAX action=dl_bfile). Kept on disk for reference; the PDB release is the canonical current version. | re-homed from jid=4054 (identity-slide repair 2026-06-12)
Full metadata
| Cause Number | FSD 0137/2019 (ASCJ) |
|---|---|
| Court | CIGC (FSD) |
| Judge | Smellie CJ |
| Parties | AA (Trustee) v BB (Attorney for Heirs) - Reasons for Decision |
| Judgment Date | 2020-02-14 |
| Subject | Trustee's proposal for realisation and distribution of trust assets and winding up of the Trust - whether Trustee may benefit only the heirs of the Settlor rather than the wider class of discretionary beneficiaries – seeming conflict between wishes of Settlor for Shari'a-compliant distributions and typical common law classification of discretionary trust beneficiaries - whether Court should nonetheless grant approval of Trustee's proposal if arrived at reasonably and after proper inquiries. |
| Filename (current) | 20-02-14-AA-v-BB.pdf |
| File MD5 | 03ae5f57ab3934341cc2532ac06397c2 |
| Source pipeline | pdb |
| PDB record ID | 3927 |
| PDB URL | https://judicial.ky/n0c-storage/judgments-repository2/20-02-14-AA-v-BB.pdf |