Judgment · jid 11706
Dwayne Robin Thompson v The King - Judgment
[2026] CICA (Crim) 3
· CICA (CRIM) APPEAL NO. 0013 OF 2024 · 2026-Feb-17
Application of R v Gorman and jurynote procedure; communication between judge and jury; whether judges handling of ambiguous jury note amounted to material irregularity; propriety of addressing jury in open court before Consulting counsel; judicial discretion not to press jurors for particulars following their second note; adequacy of judicial directions reinforcing impartiality, absence of external influence, and duty to report concerns; whether failure to inquire further created a lurking doubt affecting the safety of verdicts; assessment of whether any handling of jury notes jeopardised fairness; affirmation that convictions for robbery, possession of unlicensed firearm, and possession of ammunition were safe
Full metadata
| Neutral Citation | [2026] CICA (Crim) 3 |
|---|---|
| Cause Number | CICA (CRIM) APPEAL NO. 0013 OF 2024 |
| Court | Court of Appeal |
| Judgment Date | 2026-Feb-17 |
| Subject | Application of R v Gorman and jurynote procedure; communication between judge and jury; whether judges handling of ambiguous jury note amounted to material irregularity; propriety of addressing jury in open court before Consulting counsel; judicial discretion not to press jurors for particulars following their second note; adequacy of judicial directions reinforcing impartiality, absence of external influence, and duty to report concerns; whether failure to inquire further created a lurking doubt affecting the safety of verdicts; assessment of whether any handling of jury notes jeopardised fairness; affirmation that convictions for robbery, possession of unlicensed firearm, and possession of ammunition were safe |
| Category | Criminal |
| Filename (current) | CICACRIM0013202402172026DWAYNETHOMPSON.pdf |
| Source pipeline | csv |