October 25th – 27th, 2010

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN SUPREME COURT SAINT LUCIA FINAL CAUSE LIST [25TH TO 27TH OCTOBER, 2010] I. JUDGMENT

[1]Janice Reynolds-Greene v Community First Co-operative Credit Union [Civ. App. No. 27 of 2008] Antigua and Barbuda

[2]Jacqui Quin-Leandro et al v Dean Jonas et al [Consolidated Civ. App. Nos. 18,19 and 20 of 2010] Antigua and Barbuda Wednesday, 27th October 2010 II. APPLICATIONS [1] National Development Corporation v Jocelyn Flavius [Civ. App. No. 41 of 2008] Discontinue Appeal [2] Sheldon Fletcher v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2009] Assign Counsel to Appellant, Copy of Transcript be Provided to Counsel and Cost of Transcript be Defrayed

[3]Elias George v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 5 of 2009] Assign Counsel to Appellant, Copy of Transcript be Provided to Counsel and Cost of Transcript be Defrayed

[4]Shammal Charles v Williamson Hippolyte [Civ. App. No. 13 of 2009] Leave to Amend Notice of Appeal

[5]David Bickford v St. Lucia Estates Ltd. et al [Civ. App. No. 8 of 2010] Strike out Appeal

[6]Roland Browne v The Public Service Commission [Civ. App. No. 23 of 2010] Leave to Appeal

[7]LPA International Inc. et al v Baron Gabriel Van Der Elst [Civ. App. No. 24 of 2010] Leave to Appeal and Stay of Execution

[8]Mark Goddard v Paula Calderon [Civ. App. No. 25 of 2010] Leave to Appeal

[9]Andrea Hippolyte v Rene Trim et al [Civ. App. No. 27 of 2010] Leave to Appeal

[10]Martin Devaux v Mark Goddard [Civ. App. No. 28 of 2010] Stay of Execution

[11]Agnes St. Romain v Commissioner of Police [Mag. Crim. App. No. 1 of 2010] Extension of Time to Appeal * Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the Court III. HIGH COURT CRIMINAL APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION * [1] Earl Hunte v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 12 of 2006] Robbery IV. HIGH COURT CIVIL APPEALS * [1] Robert Auguste et al v Alexander George et al [Civ. App. No. 30 of 2005] [2] Bonifacia Noel v Gertrude Payne [Civ. App. No. 33 of 2007] *[3] Martha Adolta Henry born Louis also called Martha Adolta [Civ. App. No. 38 of 2008] Louisy qua Administratrix of the Estate of the Late Gregory Louisy) v Cora Urelien Smith (qua Tutrix of the Minor Karra Hanna Smith acting herein and represented by her duly appointed attorney Alexandra Marcelin * [4] Shammal Charles v Williamson Hippolyte [Civ. App. No. 13 of 2009] [5] Anthony John v Antoine Monero [Civ. App. No. 26 of 2009] [6] Fire Service Association v Public Service Commission et al [Civ. App. No. 13 of 2010] [7] Quality Motors Limited v Clarke Investments Limited et al [Civ. App. No. 16 of 2010] [8] Sylvia Francois Richard v The Commissioner of Crown Lands [Civ. App. No. 17 of 2010] [9] Claude Shoulette v The Attorney General [Civ. App. No. 20 of 2010] Procedural appeal STATUS HEARING I. HIGH COURT CRIMINAL APPEALS [1] Jascinta Bevan v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2007] [2] Chester King & Marlon Harris v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 4 of 2007] [3] Matthew Adjodha v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 5 of 2007] [4] Ezekiel Joseph v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 6 of 2007] [5] Justin Thomas v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 1 of 2008] [6] Jesse St. Cyr v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2008] * Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the Court [7] Alban Albert v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 3 of 2008] * [8] Francis Mathurin et al v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 4 of 2008] [9] Theresa Ann Marie Justin v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 5 of 2008] [10] Christopher Jn Paul v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 6 of 2008] [11] Simon Marius v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 7 of 2008] II. HIGH COURT CIVIL APPEALS * [1] Christopher Alsace et al v Choc Estates Limited [Civ. App. No. 25 of 2001] * [2] Parry Husbands v Herbert Jn. Baptiste et al [Civ. App. No. 40 of 2003] * [3] Headley Felicien v Rosalie Sylvester [Civ. App. No. 16 of 2006] * [4] Gundolph Calderon v St. Lucia Electricity Services Limited [Civ. App. No. 34 of 2006] * [5] Moncherry Car and Jeep Rental Limited et al v Joseph Cox [Civ. App. No. 5 of 2008] III. MAGISTERIAL CRIMINAL APPEALS [1] Julietta Prospere v Neal Stanislus PC # 603 [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2001] [2] Kurty Prospere v Neal Stanislus PC # 603 [Crim. App. No. 3 of 2001] [3] Jude Biscette v O’Neil Greene PC # 127 [Crim. App. No. 3A of 2004] [4] Earnie Severin v The Police [Crim. App. No. 8 of 2004] [5] Jerome Alexander v CPL # 416 Norville [Crim. App. No. 9 of 2004] [6] Eabran George v Commissioner of Police [Crim. App. No. 10 of 2004] [7] Arnold Auguste v Patrice Francis PC # 556 [Crim. App. No. 11 of 2004] [8] [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2005] [9] Kuanda Tuitt v The Police PC # 659 Monrose [Crim. App. No. 3 of 2005] [10] Nicholas Marcellin v Egbert S. Felix PC # 592 [Crim. App. No. 8 of 2005] [11] Kurt Sylvester v Commissioner of Police [Crim. App. No. 1 of 2007] Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the Court IV. MAGISTERIAL CIVIL APPEALS [1] Juliana Felix et al v Marie Edward et al [Crim App. No. 1 of 2003] [2] Thomas Matty Bray v Monica Maximin [Crim. App. No. 34 of 2003] [3] Earl Cenac et al v Angela Amedee [Crim. App. No. 1 of 2005] * Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the Court Chief Registrar, ECSC Finalised 22nd October, 2010

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN SUPREME COURT SAINT LUCIA FINAL CAUSE LIST [25TH TO 27TH OCTOBER, 2010] I. JUDGMENT

[1]Janice Reynolds-Greene v Community First Co-operative Credit Union [Civ. App. No. 27 of 2008] Antigua and Barbuda

[2]Jacqui Quin-Leandro et al v Dean Jonas et al [Consolidated Civ. App. Nos. 18,19 and 20 of 2010] Antigua and BarbudaWednesday, 27th October 2010 II. APPLICATIONS

[3]Elias George v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 5 of 2009] Assign Counsel to Appellant, Copy of Transcript be Provided to Counsel and Cost of Transcript be Defrayed

[4]Shammal Charles v Williamson Hippolyte [Civ. App. No. 13 of 2009] Leave to Amend Notice of Appeal

[5]David Bickford v St. Lucia Estates Ltd. et al [Civ. App. No. 8 of 2010] Strike out Appeal[6] Roland Browne v The Public Service Commission [Civ. App. No. 23 of 2010] Leave to Appeal

[6]Fire Service Association v Public Service Commission et al [Civ. App. No. 13 of 2010]

[7]LPA International Inc. et al v Baron Gabriel Van Der Elst [Civ. App. No. 24 of 2010] Leave to Appeal and Stay of Execution

[8]Mark Goddard v Paula Calderon [Civ. App. No. 25 of 2010] Leave to Appeal

[9]Andrea Hippolyte v Rene Trim et al [Civ. App. No. 27 of 2010] Leave to Appeal

[10]Martin Devaux v Mark Goddard [Civ. App. No. 28 of 2010] Stay of Execution

[11]Agnes St. Romain v Commissioner of Police [Mag. Crim. App. No. 1 of 2010] Extension of Time to Appeal Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the CourtIII. HIGH COURT CRIMINAL APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION *

[1]National Development Corporation v Jocelyn Flavius [Civ. App. No. 41 of 2008] Discontinue Appeal

[2]Sheldon Fletcher v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2009] Assign Counsel to Appellant, Copy of Transcript be Provided to Counsel and Cost of Transcript be Defrayed

[1]Earl Hunte v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 12 of 2006] RobberyIV. HIGH COURT CIVIL APPEALS *

[1]Robert Auguste et al v Alexander George et al [Civ. App. No. 30 of 2005]

[2]Bonifacia Noel v Gertrude Payne [Civ. App. No. 33 of 2007] *[3] Martha Adolta Henry born Louis also called Martha Adolta [Civ. App. No. 38 of 2008] Louisy qua Administratrix of the Estate of the Late Gregory Louisy) v Cora Urelien Smith (qua Tutrix of the Minor Karra Hanna Smith acting herein and represented by her duly appointed attorney Alexandra Marcelin *

[4]Shammal Charles v Williamson Hippolyte [Civ. App. No. 13 of 2009]

[5]Anthony John v Antoine Monero [Civ. App. No. 26 of 2009]

[7]Quality Motors Limited v Clarke Investments Limited et al [Civ. App. No. 16 of 2010]

[8]Sylvia Francois Richard v The Commissioner of Crown Lands [Civ. App. No. 17 of 2010]

[9]Claude Shoulette v The Attorney General [Civ. App. No. 20 of 2010] Procedural appeal STATUS HEARING I. HIGH COURT CRIMINAL APPEALS

[1]Jascinta Bevan v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2007]

[2]Chester King & Marlon Harris v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 4 of 2007]

[3]Matthew Adjodha v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 5 of 2007]

[4]Ezekiel Joseph v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 6 of 2007]

[5]Justin Thomas v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 1 of 2008]

[6]Jesse St. Cyr v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2008] * Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the Court

[7]Alban Albert v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 3 of 2008] *

[8]Francis Mathurin et al v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 4 of 2008]

[9]Theresa Ann Marie Justin v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 5 of 2008]

[10]Christopher Jn Paul v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 6 of 2008]

[11]Simon Marius v The Queen [Crim. App. No. 7 of 2008] II. HIGH COURT CIVIL APPEALS *

[1]Christopher Alsace et al v Choc Estates Limited [Civ. App. No. 25 of 2001] *

[2]Parry Husbands v Herbert Jn. Baptiste et al [Civ. App. No. 40 of 2003] *

[3]Headley Felicien v Rosalie Sylvester [Civ. App. No. 16 of 2006] *

[4]Gundolph Calderon v St. Lucia Electricity Services Limited [Civ. App. No. 34 of 2006] *

[5]Moncherry Car and Jeep Rental Limited et al v Joseph Cox [Civ. App. No. 5 of 2008] III. MAGISTERIAL CRIMINAL APPEALS

[1]Julietta Prospere v Neal Stanislus PC # 603 [Crim. App. No. 2 of 2001]

[2]Kurty Prospere v Neal Stanislus PC # 603 [Crim. App. No. 3 of 2001]

[3]Jude Biscette v O’Neil Greene PC # 127 [Crim. App. No. 3A of 2004]

[4]Earnie Severin v The Police [Crim. App. No. 8 of 2004]

[5]Jerome Alexander v CPL # 416 Norville [Crim. App. No. 9 of 2004]

[6]Eabran George v Commissioner of Police [Crim. App. No. 10 of 2004]

[7]Arnold Auguste v Patrice Francis PC # 556 [Crim. App. No. 11 of 2004]

[8][Crim. App. No. 2 of 2005]

[9]Kuanda Tuitt v The Police PC # 659 Monrose [Crim. App. No. 3 of 2005]

[10]Nicholas Marcellin v Egbert S. Felix PC # 592 [Crim. App. No. 8 of 2005]

[11]Kurt Sylvester v Commissioner of Police [Crim. App. No. 1 of 2007] * Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the CourtIV. MAGISTERIAL CIVIL APPEALS

[1]Juliana Felix et al v Marie Edward et al [Crim App. No. 1 of 2003]

[2]Thomas Matty Bray v Monica Maximin [Crim. App. No. 34 of 2003]

[3]Earl Cenac et al v Angela Amedee [Crim. App. No. 1 of 2005] * Adjourned from the Last Sitting of the Court Chief Registrar, ECSC Finalised 22nd October, 2010