O’Neil McIntosh FOR ORDER OF MANAGEMENT

S!..IUT VHTCE:rT. - IN '.rIIE RIG!I COURT OF' In/,~T (CIVIL) .,' r , SUIT NO. 1i30 of.. 1Q73. / \ In tho Df',ttor of r.,n npplico.tion by 0 'Noill NO\'lSD.IJ Hc Intosh for an ardor of }':,~l1Cl['J:1US. and In the n:J.ttor of 2.n applicn.tion by the sc.id ,. o'noill N'mm:--.r.l ~~c Intooh to the ReCiot::-o..r of joint stock CO~lpo,nioG for a cortificc.tQ of incorporation thr::.t u Coop.::~ny by tl:c nO.rla of "Hoalth Sorvices Linitod" W::l.O duly il~,corpor'"'..ted on tho 7th d['.y of r·'[(';.y, 1973, nncl th,:,,:t the said CODpany is liLlited. I E • .l:'.C. Hughoo for e.p)liccmt. N. Joseph, Log2.l _'.soiot,:mt for rospom1ent. 1973 July 2.9.. -------,----­ BERS.IDGE ,J. \ Tho a.pplicnnt, 0 'Neill Newsan 1ic Int'Jsh of Indicn Bay, SE'.int Vincent, D. cOL1pany diroctor, seeks an order of nandX1UG directod to the Rogistrar of Joint stock Conpnnies colltlanding her forthwith to certify utl.dor her hand thC1..t a. CO'.':lp8.ny by :bhe of "Honlth Servicos Linitcd ll /duly••••••

-2­ ~ .duly in.corj),)rc:l:;cc1 ';l-:' the 7th (~;'.y of 1973, . £':.1lc1 that the said Company is lirrited, .leave o:f ,> the Court to apply for such an order having been • . -, granted to the applicant on the 21st June, 1973_ The grounds upon which the relief is sought .are that­ •• (a) Early in May, 1973, the IIemorandum and Articles of Association of a Company to be called "Health Serviccs IJimited" signed by the Applic.::lnt al1.(1 six other· persons Here delivered to t~lO 11ogis­ trar of joint stock Conpanies for registration pursuant to the provisions of Section 14(t) of tho CO~~~l)anies Act, Chapter 219. (b) On the 7th day of l\lay, 1973, tile fees required to be paid by tho s:1.id Act 1'lere paid to the Registrar of joint stock COIJpanies and a proper anc~ v:::lid re­ ceipt 'was obtained for the S81Je. (c) The said Registrar of joint stock Companies has, since the 7th d::.;y- of •, ~by, 1973, without latlful justifica­ tion or excuse, refused to issuo a certificC'.te of the incorpor2.tion of tho sC'.id Company as she is req1-ured to do by Section 15(1) of the Coo­ pani8s ~ct, Chapter 219.

On tho 8th rL\y, 1973, the Ree;intr"r of joint stock COI::lp2.nics (h,;rc:in;~fter ~~'oforrGc~ to :.'.;3 the Registrr::.r) addrossee] a letter to t~~-..: itor .J for to rogistc,r the (Joupm1.Y in the 3bscl1ce 0:": " lico:;:lCO i[:1plied fron the Governor G.S the nc:ne of t}'lG " . cd 25.LI' ~- 1 " t" "'l"''''Y, .4 •• ", .I fron I tho tr.1.r t . , advico, I • I I t ~G;.l-C G:fOI'CL~c11tioncd =cc ___~r.;Clll. j ~ COUl1.Gol (0.) tllO nUl1u~\..lldun of ,::,ssocic"t t th::lt thcrc".,ftor ~ ill conpl:L.~ncc uith ooct::"on 15 the .:i.:'"t;er rOlorrc;cL to ,~~.::; the.ct) 1 t: tllO C ificLtO[~lS conpulsory. (b) the [lp:~:lic.:~tion fell uithir:.. the • G juscL).. l &3no1"'i3 itulo. i1 /(c) ...•• ~ j I

-4­ (c) on a clo::~r nonning the ti·t:lc.; of tho COLllX~ny did not the pro­ viaiom3 of the ~...ct. section 14(1) of tho ~ct for tho delivery • of tho fc1Cr.wr. aGsoci~tion, bin and ro ~3 tho GCl.LlO 11hilo a ion 14(2) pro­ .. 8cribo& tho pc.yablo to tho pqny. It is convoniunt Qt this G to sot out in oxtens",9 IH'cvioiOl1S of :elect 15 ( 1) and 17 • (1) • f tho IJ.onOrnndl'll of nos(lci,;"tL\~'l., of tho nrt tu oh8.11 under his h8..11.0. cu Conpany ifJ DO toe:' co:pc~ny thc~.t Conpnny is • :C~, i. terod­ • • "17(1) Undur or Gh::~ll :0 uoo of p il.ny n~LlO or t 9 including ilQUOOl1S;; "RoY::1.1 tl or 11CrO\!ll1l /niCht •••

-5­ Dight cmLVey the '.,jution of ROy<J.l or otlll.T C'OV J:'llDont patrol1c:.[G or sup- ,11l'lL~sG the GoV(;rll(:t'" Shf'.11 ,.~riting viously givon hie J.iCl)'lCO in tb.::.t behalf. n Tho rucoilJ-G i3suod to tho applic,?.nt':J Egolicitor " r' • is , 1973, and r0~ds ":'''!--' i~(;llo\.rC2 : ­ :] the SUIn Cl;lY fror' :c ._'... C. vd.COG Ltd 240.60 fl ~c1c1ro[)!J 1.20 f1 nono .. /..ng(:l;::. Prin.co for l~CC(;,UYlt ~nt Y' .1. II C01..illsol for tIl,,; J.ospondont CO;lt .·iJ tho moro receipt of tho foeo frOl! tho co did not 1::1eo.n that ro.:;;istr ,1,-[;i011 of tho ; lGnc:r,~ ... of o.oooci8.­ end Grticloo of ~sGoci~tioll contcntiO:Ll CnUl18 quoted section 9(1) of tho Rcgis­ th::-..t it trnr's Ordi:1anc() Cap. 149 L 1111.ic11 pr0viclos 811all bo the du:l;y of tho ROG.istr:.r to " • colloct all foos p ,yc::.b10 to th.,~t of£ic01' hoi'oro tho

-6­ acts, in rOSi)(;ct of llhich they 2rc pC:y2 ~)le, arc por­ (:301111cl up to.'\, had tho • articles of'..,]ooc t foc:s th2:t r"l[,,~y ~jo11 ' ',va beon .'1 co 1")1(: C;j',,:;TJCX' to this 2pp1ic;::1.tion• . . In tho CQOO, hoyovor, nomor',nc1ur1 of ;'.L'G()cL~tiun :::tnd t;lC but the tion boon duly d tc tho • pc.ni00 on the 7th 3, 1973, :mu :,\ ,]~::i" l1unbor assiened to tho Con,;)'~ny. Tho question to be dotol~nin\.Jc1 i8 t con­ stitutos rc.~:i3t:':'DJ~ion of the L1e~,lOr of -:.tf.Jsocia­ tiOl1 CLnd n.. rticl 0 of aoocci~~ticn? It dOOL not :.~l1pc::~r tlr,t thoro ic c:.ny specified bJok or rUL:,istor 'i'ihich those c10CUj:1Cll-(;fJ c,ro fornnlly • • the ReGister of COL1.}Xll1i(;s cOl1otitutos rcLf5tration

-7­ joction of tho vit;o..l doeUDont-::.upon 11hieh the Gxis­ tonco of the lpC'-llY do},)(;ndfJ, 011e of 'iT~licb. IH'ovideo, int~r :~lio." for t:.le vury n~:'1v of tho C.)j' ..'·my• • I find thor():Coro tll,l.t sLmlt,.. lou1..1bly \lith tho rmd r:.rticlcs of :"'..Gooei,"'..tion tionjof tho Con:i!-:.n;'/ '~TOrd roc;iotol' • obliGed to of 1I1.;,y, 1973, . ! .. "1 . .~" v _. J...\...,,' o~id :J:::' 80e­ tion 1.5 (1 ) of ;.,urit in tho o.,rticlao of i'.lJijocL~tion ITcro not duly :cu ::i.ntorod I Ifill turn to tIl,:.; :JGccmd linb of ,.re:c'.: by Counool for tlh;',pplie:,nt. R. v Edn'lmdo..Jll [f855il 2 E & E 77 i8 ,~uthority for o::yinC th:'d; \TL...J:t.~o thero c..rc:: GOllcJ:'~l F~n'clG follow­ .1 Hordo nuot bo • confined. to oubj acto ejusdoD generio .."'..0 t~lOSO spocified or, to put it in ~nothor u~'.y, ,{hon Genor""l vlOrds follo11 0 c:Lfic :rTOrao the I·· " ~. -.\,.., ... ...

GP..I:10 kind uhioh Tront boforo; ~~nc1 conotitut-.: 8;).ch :: co.togory, 01..:0;] or CC,llUU ~ thm only or gonus fo.ll uithin tllo :' ,on.:;:;:-':,l uorde. von • porn.tiOl'l Lr95~7t 1..11 E. R. 205, 0' .fJ:: (1)1 uhich Coun­ • '0'110:.1ting obstructi'~n of public procos",d.on;J, rojoicing or jJh1~ ~i n·'3;iul1.n 9 cmd or 1inhlc in o..ny 0;'.,00 tJ.lO FJtrocta to be obDtx·uct(.·cl ••• a ~ , • " ~ •• 0 ii r.l~" \...; \.Jrdor do.tcd 0 CI • in effeot o1'" C;[':(; NC'.rcll 5 ~ 1957, ' trnffic syotOl1 joininc; DtrcCC;J uithin tho district of tho lou:'.l::.u:thority for '~ll vohicloe for • six 1:;, 1957, to October 19, 1957, fur t:~e rC~;J:)n tJ1.:'.:c du:cil1G cor­

-9­ thronged li::.blc should bo inter ..;d OjUOd0rl gonorio linited • to C:l.800 0 -L -c rojoicinga, or ilh::lin l,tLms it fined to o:::tr'l-ordin'.l'Y occ~"sions • ~1nd did not ,.:m~~blo ':'1.1'1 period ;10 .19, 1957 to Oct. 19, 1957 to bo L1::.(10 • • Ex p,>.rto LT91gl Vul .. 81. K.B. D. 914 t i[i not ro:<.lly t ill th,,,t for :( eo to rogiotcr t on tll0 rC{:ioL;r 01" COi.18idor:1,tion tionnry po~vo:;:,,'3 • • Hovurthel\,;oL, tho follouing r"L:;v;-'.llt :principles , ,t ommic :2-:,1 tilia c"",oo:- nre of int0~eGt Ii . ...

, -10­ III think to juctify -Chi,; COl)" in intor­ of tho . - , v - y;: one or net in principle ,')f h '.:.; uCGn ir~flucncod 8(, things i:l"lt::d:; bo n',(10 ()l",t:; justify tIlis Cocct in interfor­ • Servicoo Linit ;: ",r~ [;0no:c H orclr; :.' o,::.nnot be ruoo. t in fj(;ction • " -.1 tll Servicos 17 ( 1 ) of n,oy::::.l or • I,oc:::1 Govorn­ 1::.lOnt 9 proc1ucoc1 in ovidellCJ. c d~ted 16th Fobru' 1973, fro~: tho C;--.binot Sccrotl.ry reInting to ~... r:.~~(lic" n;:-~ttor 20ncl • he opined. rcl;:"t.:) -Co Jche on- ServiceD;: 'Hl:.ieh

-11­ he::.Itth :3 by nut 1:'0 :L[; "..::d under 1 IL>'~lth" , • tho COl1p:!"ni,-c ....ot. • in. his vie\!, nont in thG 0,"..8e of '. ~n tho npub1io :1th ]Jngino L:ring Unit:; • • Tho uj not opinion convoy the m,lG{ () f~ or to oupport ~C:'ing , dopartn()ntCl1 00;1] pocliti:m. 0d. Thore.: vli11 bo :<.n ordor to bofore tho 11 -eh j'uly ~ 1973 to cort hor Linited 11 ,·rao d'LLly :L:worpor:;.ted or::. • •

--1 2-­ '.ti()~l to be -c~xod in de ',ult cnt,. .. • II. ! • I i t I

SUIT No.130 of 1973, Berridge ,J. Delivered: 09/07/73