DANA McINTOSH et al v HUBERT PAUL et al

/ SAINT LUCIA: I:" THE HIGH COl RT OF JUSTICE (Ci\il) '\0: 72 of 1994 Bet\\een Dt','\:\' \IC I:\TOSH .., \10:\ c\ \Ie I:"ITOSH \<s II CHERT P<\ l L ALOYSIA THEOPHILCS \1r. :\ \1c:\clIl1QI"Q !,). 1 ...... ;it C\'" L ' 199q: .JCDG;\IENT d' :\.llvcr~lle J. IIl~JJ2lU: \ ,:;..'~' \ '\ i, cLHed \ hnch, C k,lrh c:ilo\\s that the [)e ~lC k illterest in the S Ll ~ [ \\'ETC' :11 ~'llcI \\ere :l(l\i to <tate of the matter es names were . the trial and second named led on hehalf the III ti i:linti tl g:l\ e e\ v " l'l inti luid ';'e ' purr tl1m 011 hnuarv. 993 at JDuut I:::, nool1. \\'as lI1g motorcar \ll lilthL' II"SlI)lai It'!' (1\\l1el". from I1C\ LSd\ \hlrllla into the "- rHO another side road said that to <i~., '~~lh:t \)11 (Jr' the \brina side said she was c ! \() til it'll ~llld rl there \\~1~~1'" \en \ en I~ir rJ she indicated ,I' 'II II:C: !lllt Ilild actcd accordi \ til L'I1 Bellil )l1ce morc n Ie sa\\ the way still a ,\\\ 11\ .. ,Ill ~l1e \\as 1111110Sl Into the cn1rance 01' that Side llldl"C ~he IIltO the re[lI'\IC\\ IllI!TOr on to S[1 \\ was rng the on the de Ing , \\115 almost 011 ShL' :illid thllt that lime ,shc hlld three quarters of her car into the Bella r(lad. \\hen the Cell' number second Ilamed Dekndant collided with the bllek u( her el!'. clUsing It to ]lei ,-lllll \."~lu;;('d it tP llc ~l rl otT." She <lid that it she e ill \ Hit II) l' ~i I1llllute:i \\lll'11 ~ht' rt'gai consciousness she J ne \\ ho 11ssisteli nut car,

1.dro\e them to the ,'\",\ ·2· ... ~~~:\::J :':"". I.,,:h 1 1:'11.;;:: fn \!I~\·It\; he!' \~f1!'tl(ll!l~11';';: f"1..1:)~CiHl dy\'T,qi?~~ viz: 1. Wrecker Service 50.00 (' \)C \ kckmical 1::'. , C 1 motor car rt.:ntai L'om hl1U;Jn .~ to I " .. 1 .500.00 \ kdicai E':pcnses ., She cbimed of \ lotorcar :\ul1lber (,()21 less :;al\age \:dlle :H S 1 O.OOO(H) :~RGLJ\lE:\T: e:lrned the the oy that ice Re confirmed the P::lillti s case that I c!1lE1nl :lS drt\lI1g \\ ilh e':ceSst\\: 11l an area two III inor rO:lds. :11:;\ ) that the Pb ld be InIUrleS :;uswined by the :;econd 11Cimed :md the 1 i ~c'li((, \J C ~ecol1d n:ll11ed Delend::!] concluded h submitting the I)e . CUlInterclC111l1 be l,;i"". \\ lth c()sts. CO:\CIXSIO:\: [)!:1 i III I lIon \\'/1' :lIT1\e :1t :1 cOl1cl confirm:; the s a car ling ahe:~ld and collided IIh the: of car 6021 which \vas an turn into Bella ROS~1 Road." SPECIAL DAMAGES: exhi conrirm all the: la:-:..; :111ec 1 ~ll ~ 1 1!1 the: m. therefore should a\\ arc! Plaint! ,,': 1-\.33':; ,-' 1 <.ll ~ 11 L' l: damages and interest at rate or to GENERAL DAl\lAGES: second ff l. c1un :)ll:)t~llned miuries to (t and the: dO~'Lil11eIH~lr\ e\ I(\e::\.'-: Dr. \1. IZ')~l' \.,) : lrllh lhere \\-ould be "over :'0% eli llt'the use ut her kn h~11 eeks." latest cases ), \::i DeudcJt ! C i\i i Virgin b cmel Felll"!1\ \:-; I t':l ~\T)l ( . i :\0. 6 )(SL LLlCi~l) C,)!l:::cklL'd. award !1cll11ed P1:11111111 Sl S5 for the named De ~1\vard interest on ~he Counterclaim is \vant 0 ORDER therefore the PI~\1 In sum of S29.335.00 (S14.335.0(l) ~l~ clill1 15.UOO.OO as interest as StIpU to the Plaintiffs to be agreed or otherWlse taxed. . c\ . . . . . . . ~ ------"- ... ~.,., SUZIE d' ~ ...........

Suit No. 72 of 1994 D’Auvergne, J Delivered: 17/05/99